Tire shops · Sarasota Guide

10 Sarasota Tire shops Worth Knowing

Our local guide to finding tire shops in 2027: 10 businesses, and what each does best.

By the editors of The Local List Updated 37 businesses considered

Ask around Sarasota for tire shops and you’ll hear a handful of names and three quotes that look nothing alike. These 10 stood out from the 37 we compared. They aren’t ranked: each carries a label for what it does best.

How we chose

Open businesses with a phone number and enough real reviews to judge fairly, compared on ratings, review history, years in business and record checks. No business paid to be included.

Read our full methodology · How we make money · Spotted an error?

The list

10 tire shops, and what each does best

Also on the list

Also considered

More tire shops in Sarasota

The other businesses we compared for this guide. Ratings and review counts are from public review platforms.

  • Goodyear Auto Service · Sarasota · 4.5 from 195 (2021) reviews
  • JSN Auto Repair-Sarasota · Sarasota · 4.5 from 185 (2021) reviews
  • E.V. Discount Tire · Sarasota · 4.7 from 65 (2021) reviews
  • Jiffy Lube · Sarasota · 4.5 from 165 (2021) reviews
  • Bt Tires · Sarasota · 4.6 from 148 (2021) reviews
  • Quick Lane Tire & Auto Center · Sarasota · 4.6 from 76 (2021) reviews
  • I-75 Tires & Maintenance · Sarasota · 4.8 from 35 (2021) reviews
  • Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center · Sarasota · 4.4 from 164 (2021) reviews
  • Tires Plus · Sarasota · 4.4 from 158 (2021) reviews
  • Lanning Tire Sales - Cooper Tire · Sarasota · 4.6 from 88 (2021) reviews
  • Tire Place Auto Center · Sarasota · 4.6 from 88 (2021) reviews
  • Action Auto Center · Sarasota · 4.6 from 42 (2021) reviews
  • Brian's Auto Repair, Inc · Sarasota · 4.5 from 58 (2021) reviews
  • Jiffy Lube · Sarasota · 4.3 from 176 (2021) reviews
  • Jiffy Lube · Sarasota · 4.3 from 172 (2021) reviews
  • Goodyear Auto Service · Sarasota · 4.3 from 128 (2021) reviews
  • Tire Kingdom · Sarasota · 4.3 from 124 (2021) reviews
  • Midas · Sarasota · 4.3 from 117 (2021) reviews
  • Junior's Tire Service · Sarasota · 4.9 from 18 (2021) reviews
  • Goodyear Auto Service · Sarasota · 4.3 from 88 (2021) reviews
  • 301 Tires · Sarasota · 4.3 from 83 (2021) reviews
  • Car Tune Up - Sarasota · Sarasota · 4.6 from 28 (2021) reviews
  • Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires · Sarasota · 4.1 from 148 (2021) reviews
  • American European Autos · Sarasota · 4.1 from 98 (2021) reviews
  • Tire Kingdom · Sarasota · 4.0 from 138 (2021) reviews
  • Majestic Motors - Automotive Service Center · Sarasota · 4.3 from 28 (2021) reviews
  • Tires Plus · Sarasota · 4.0 from 98 (2021) reviews

Side by side

The 10 at a glance

Tire shops, Sarasota, October 31, 2026
BusinessLabelRatingReviewsYearsPrice
Manny's Tires Inc.Editor’s Pick4.7676––
Beiler's Auto Repair–4.9185 (2021)––
Tom Dion's Automotive Repair–4.9157 (2021)––
Motion Tire–4.9135 (2021)––
Automotive Service Garage–5.087 (2021)––
University Tires Plus–4.6635––
Sherman's Auto Repair–4.953 (2021)––
Tire Choice Auto Service Centers–4.6198 (2021)––
Jon Wayne Diesel Performance–4.868 (2021)––
Gettel Hyundai of SarasotaReader Favorite4.32856––

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.

Hiring guide

Before you sign with anyone on this list

The best businesses welcome these questions. If a company dodges them, keep looking.

  1. Check the license. Where your state requires one for this work, look it up on the state’s licensing site before anyone visits, not after.
  2. Get written quotes for the same scope. Ask each company to price the same job, materials and equipment so you’re comparing like with like. Our Sarasota cost guide shows what drives the price.
  3. Ask who handles permits. If the job needs one, the company should pull it and tell you how long it usually takes.
  4. Read the payment schedule. Payments should follow progress, with a modest deposit up front.
  5. Get the warranty in writing. Know what’s covered, for how long, and whether it transfers if you sell.

Get quotes

Ask these companies for a price

Tick the companies you want to hear from. Only the companies you tick receive your details.

Send my request to

We pass your details only to the companies ticked above. We may earn a referral fee when a company receives a request; it never affects who appears in our guides. How we make money.

Your questions

Frequently asked questions

How did the editors choose these tire shops in Sarasota?

Editors shortlist businesses with strong ratings and enough reviews, check their records, and choose the final picks against the published criteria. We compared 37 tire shops for Sarasota. Paid placements never change the order.

Which of these tire shops in Sarasota has the best reviews?

Automotive Service Garage has a 5.0 rating from 87 (2021) (2021) public reviews, the highest on this page.

Which of these tire shops has the most reviews?

Gettel Hyundai of Sarasota, with 2856 public reviews. A long review history shows how a business handles many jobs.

Are these tire shops licensed?

10 of the 10 businesses here had their state license checked against public records. Each profile shows the source and the date of the check.

How many quotes should I get for tire shops in Sarasota?

Get at least three. Use the quote form on this page: only the businesses you tick receive your request.

Why aren’t the businesses ranked?

Because the right company depends on the job. Each business carries a label that says what it does best, so you can pick the one that fits yours.

Keep reading

More Sarasota guides

Tire shops in other editions